Do Perennials Die in Winter? No, They're Napping.
Every November, someone looks out at a bed of brown stems and asks the question.
"Did I kill them?"
Almost certainly not.
THEY'RE NOT DEAD. THEY'RE NAPPING.
WHAT'S ACTUALLY HAPPENING
Perennials in our climate are built for winter. As the days get shorter and the nights get colder, they start shutting down on purpose. This is called dormancy.
Sugars and starches move from the leaves down into the roots and crown, where they're stored for spring. The leaves and stems above ground stop working and die back. That's the brown part you're looking at.
The roots and crown, at or just below the soil surface, are very much alive. They're just resting.
WHY BROWN IS GOOD
A plant that goes dormant properly is a plant that's ready for winter. Those stored sugars work a bit like antifreeze in the cells and help protect them from freezing damage.
The brown stems are useful too. They catch snow, which insulates the crown, and they give overwintering insects somewhere to shelter.
DEAD-LOOKING. HARD-WORKING.
NOT ALL OF THEM GO BROWN
Some perennials keep their leaves all winter. Bergenia, Heuchera, Hellebores and Christmas fern stay green under the snow. They're dormant too, just with their coats on.
SO WHAT ACTUALLY KILLS PERENNIALS IN WINTER?
- Wet soil. Roots sitting in cold, waterlogged soil can rot. This is the big one.
- Freeze-thaw cycles. Repeated freezing and thawing can push young plants up out of the ground.
- The wrong zone. A Zone 7 plant in a Zone 5 garden is on borrowed time.
- Voles. They tunnel under the snow and chew on crowns.
We'll dig into the usual suspects in January.
HOW TO TELL IN SPRING
If you're not sure, wait. Some perennials, like Baptisia, Balloon Flower and Butterfly Weed, are famously late to wake up. Give them until June before you dig anything out.
Brown isn't dead.
BROWN IS BEDTIME.